Stoic week, and a challenge to Christianity
By Mark Vernon on Wednesday, November 28 2012, 17:02 - In the news - Permalink
Stoic Week looks like a genuinely interesting and valuable experiment. But two things struck me that I think are worth pondering.
First, there's no mention in the online literature of the logos - the divine principle that ancient stoics believed ran through all things and which meant you could trust life, even when it seemed to be going wrong. The basic aim of stoic practices was to align yourself to the logos, hence the meaning of going with the flow. It was not just any old flow.
Then, I see no mention of the stoic preoccupation with divination, the attempt to discern the logos by looking at the outer world of the heavens, which was thought to mirror the inner world of the self. Of course, astrology is suspect these days, but to lose touch with divination risks also losing touch with contemplating how the outer mirrors the inner, and vice versa, and that might render modern stoicism a solipsistic, lonely enterprise.
I guess the reason why the organisers felt they had to drop these theological elements is that they feel they won't run today. This is something that Christians might think about, because there is, in fact, a version of ancient stoicism that is alive and kicking in much of the world today, namely Christianity.
St Paul cites stoic thinkers and hymnody when, say, he talks about God as being that principle in which we live and move and have our being. St John too implies that Christ is the logos incarnate. Stoic practices such as reflecting on the day were incorporated into Christian liturgies and habits.
The question I am left with is whether Christianity has become so front-loaded with doctrinal ideology that we've lost touch with the fact that it too is fundamentally a way of life that is meaningless without the practices?














Comments
Well I'm going to sit down to an epicurean repast while I read Lucretius. Enjoy, have fun.
Going with the flow is quite pertinent, especially in the SW.
Mark, do you know if there is anything we have recorded about what Epictetus thought of Jesus of Nazareth or the early Christians?
I don't think Epictetus comments on early Christianity, no, but I think one of the reasons why his Handbook survives is because it was used by the early Christian monks...
If you are ready to watch comical videos on the web then I suggest you to go to see this web site, it consists of actually so comic not only video clips but also additional stuff.