Doing it my way
By Mark Vernon on Sunday, July 11 2010, 09:27 - Religion - Permalink
I'm instinctively wary of the pic'n'mix approach to belief and spirituality, mostly because I'm quite a pic'n'mixer myself. It's the worry of never engaging the deeper riches of any single practice or way of life, which requires decades to do. And Jung suggests to me that might be right, via his concept of individuation.
By that account, the story of our lives is, first, the establishment of the ego, in the ways of the world; and second, the displacement of the ego by the Self - that wider participation in life, variously referred to as embracing the flow of life, fuller consciousness, the way, God. One needs the other: the Self needs an established ego fully to be in the world; the ego needs the Self to find not just instrumental purpose but ontological meaning.
Today, this rise and then eclipse of the ego is disrupted because the ego may never find the security it needs to first establish itself, what with the multiple choices on offer in the contemporary world: in a plural culture of many ways, and lots of pic'n'mix, it's hard to be committed to one way for long enough. The situation is exacerbated because consumerism celebrates the freedom of the ego - the freedom to experiment with this and then that. In a way, it's fascinating. Though the price is never sinking roots.
However, the Self seeks to make itself known no less. And the result is individuals in a perpetual state of meaning-seeking - we're all visionaries and mystics now - though we all also share a particular characteristic: unlike our forebears who sought meaning too, through their inherited tradition, contemporary seeking is marked by the constant fear that what we seek lies elsewhere. The risk is that instead of a steady process of individuation, we live lives of constant skirmishing between ego and Self. Or to put it another way, the commitment of the New Age is not to 'the way', for who can believe there is a 'the way' anymore; but instead to 'my way'.










Comments
Hi! I really enjoyed this entry as one who is sincerely interested in philosophy of mind. I will comment a little on some of the things you've written here so that you can get my view on it :-)
"The situation is exacerbated because consumerism celebrates the freedom of the ego - the freedom to experiment with this and then that. In a way, it's fascinating. Though the price is never sinking roots."
I totally agree. The consumerism supports the freedom of the ego, but not the Self. What do you think is freedom of the Self? Would be interesting to get your opinion on this. This debate could be related to a discussion on neo-liberalism... A market that perhaps only promotes egoistic consumers habits, and degrades the unique Self that which cannot be put a price on.
"The risk is that instead of a steady process of individuation, we live lives of constant skirmishing between ego and Self"
The reason why I think this is so is because one has to discard and choose one over another, thus making way for the Self always above the ego in order to develop ones personality towards self-actualization. I think this way of living in a constant skirmishing between ego and Self is a part of being human. Perhaps this was your view as well?
Very interesting though, I'll see if I can post some on other things you have written here.
Sincerely,
Eivind